India’s decision to leave Mohammed Siraj out of the Wellington Test sparked strong reactions from former cricketers. While Shubman Gill explained the selection challenge, batting coach Sitanshu Kotak defended the team’s combination after New Zealand recovered on Day 1.
Mohammed Siraj’s absence from India’s playing XI for the first Test against New Zealand became one of the biggest talking points at the Basin Reserve in Wellington on November 19. India opted for four specialist fast bowlers, but Siraj was not among them. Instead, captain Shubman Gill and the team management backed Jasprit Bumrah, Akash Deep, Anshul Kamboj and Prasidh Krishna.
The decision surprised several former Indian cricketers, particularly because Siraj has been an established part of India’s Test attack. Sunil Gavaskar, Wasim Jaffer, Harsha Bhogle and Ravi Shastri questioned the omission, while the team management maintained that the selected combination was designed for the demands of the entire five-day match.
The debate grew louder after New Zealand recovered from 70/5 to reach 243/5 at stumps on Day 1. However, the day’s batting display alone cannot establish whether Siraj’s presence would have changed the outcome. The selection decision needs to be understood through the team’s combination, the captain’s explanation and the reactions that followed.
Table of Contents
- What Happened in India’s Playing XI?
- What Shubman Gill Said About Siraj
- Why Former Cricketers Questioned the Decision
- Sitanshu Kotak Defends India’s Selection
- Did New Zealand’s Day 1 Recovery Intensify the Debate?
- Could Siraj Return for the Next Test?
- What the Selection Debate Means for India
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Final Verdict
What Happened in India’s Playing XI Against New Zealand?
India won the toss in Wellington and elected to field first. The team went with a four-man pace attack, but the final combination did not include Siraj. Ravindra Jadeja was also left out, with Washington Sundar selected as the spin-bowling all-rounder.
India’s playing XI featured Jasprit Bumrah, Akash Deep, Anshul Kamboj and Prasidh Krishna as the four seam options. Washington Sundar provided the spin-bowling option, while Rishabh Pant returned to the side.
| Selection Detail | India’s Decision |
|---|---|
| Captain | Shubman Gill |
| Fast bowlers selected | Bumrah, Akash Deep, Kamboj and Prasidh Krishna |
| Spin-bowling option | Washington Sundar |
| Not selected | Mohammed Siraj and Ravindra Jadeja |
| Toss decision | India elected to field |
| Venue | Basin Reserve, Wellington |
The decision was not a simple choice between a pace bowler and a spinner. India selected four seamers but preferred Kamboj and Akash Deep over the more experienced Siraj. That was the specific selection call that drew the strongest reaction.
What Did Shubman Gill Say About Mohammed Siraj’s Omission?
At the toss, Gill acknowledged that selecting the bowling combination had been difficult. He explained that the team had spent the previous week discussing its options because several fast bowlers had been performing well.
Gill also made it clear that Siraj and Gurnoor Brar were unfortunate to miss out. His explanation pointed towards competition within India’s pace group rather than an announced injury or disciplinary issue involving Siraj.
The captain’s comments are important because they establish the team’s stated position: India had multiple fast-bowling options and had to choose a combination. They do not, however, explain every technical reason behind preferring Kamboj and Akash Deep.
For that, the team management’s post-Day 1 explanation offered further context.
Why Did Former Cricketers Question India’s Decision?
Siraj’s omission drew criticism from several well-known voices in Indian cricket. Their concern centred on his experience, work rate and ability to support the attack in overseas conditions.
Sunil Gavaskar Questions the Selection
Sunil Gavaskar expressed surprise at the decision and said he did not believe Siraj had done anything to lose his place. He also pointed to the experience gap between Siraj and some of the fast bowlers selected ahead of him.
Gavaskar did not claim that Siraj would automatically have taken more wickets. His broader concern was that India’s attack was missing an experienced bowler who could help maintain pressure when the initial conditions changed.
Wasim Jaffer Calls the Omission Difficult to Understand
Wasim Jaffer also questioned the decision. He said he could understand the case for Washington Sundar over Ravindra Jadeja, considering New Zealand’s left-handed batters, but found Siraj’s exclusion much harder to justify.
Jaffer highlighted Siraj’s contribution during the England series and his value as a bowler who can build pressure through sustained spells.
Harsha Bhogle and Ravi Shastri Add to the Debate
Harsha Bhogle expressed disappointment on social media, praising Siraj’s contribution when Bumrah was unavailable and describing him as a positive team player.
Ravi Shastri also questioned the omission. His reaction focused on the value of pace, skill, seam movement and experience in Wellington conditions.
These reactions show how strongly some former players disagreed with the call. They remain expert opinions, not confirmation that the selected bowlers were incapable of doing the job.
Sitanshu Kotak Defends India’s Selection Decision
India’s batting coach Sitanshu Kotak defended the team management after the opening day’s play. He said there was nothing wrong with Siraj and maintained that the team believed it had selected the best combination for the match.
Kotak’s main argument was that a Test team cannot be selected only for the first day. The management had considered the demands of all five days, including how the attack might operate as the pitch and match conditions changed.
He also explained the preference for Washington Sundar over Jadeja by pointing to the four left-handed batters in New Zealand’s top order. That gave India a specific tactical reason for choosing Sundar as its spin-bowling option.
Kotak’s comments did not suggest that Siraj was injured or out of favour permanently. They presented the omission as a combination-based decision for this particular Test.
Did New Zealand’s Day 1 Recovery Intensify the Siraj Debate?
India’s opening spell put New Zealand under serious pressure. The hosts slipped to 70/5 before Henry Nicholls and Glenn Phillips produced a substantial recovery.
At stumps, New Zealand were 243/5 after 82 overs. Nicholls was unbeaten on 113, while Phillips had reached 94 not out. Their unbroken sixth-wicket partnership was worth 173 runs.
| India Bowler | Figures |
|---|---|
| Jasprit Bumrah | 17 overs, 52 runs, 3 wickets |
| Anshul Kamboj | 18 overs, 57 runs, 1 wicket |
| Akash Deep | 15 overs, 33 runs, 1 wicket |
| Prasidh Krishna | 16 overs, 58 runs, 0 wickets |
| Washington Sundar | 16 overs, 38 runs, 0 wickets |
The partnership gave critics another reason to revisit the selection, especially because Siraj is known for delivering long spells and maintaining pressure. But it would be unfair to conclude that his inclusion would certainly have broken the stand.
India had already taken five wickets, and the selected bowlers had contributed to that early progress. The issue is whether the team could have benefited from Siraj’s experience during the middle and later stages of the innings. That remains a legitimate debate rather than a proven match outcome.
Read our NZ vs India 1st Test Day 1 match report for the full score and session-by-session match coverage.
Could Mohammed Siraj Return for the Next Test?
Siraj’s omission from the Wellington playing XI does not automatically mean he has been dropped from the entire New Zealand series. The available team comments describe a selection decision for the first Test.
His chances in the next match will depend on the team’s assessment of the conditions, the performance of the selected bowlers and the balance India wants from its attack.
If India wants additional experience and sustained pace pressure, Siraj remains an option. However, no confirmed decision about the next Test’s playing XI should be assumed before the team announcement.
What the Siraj Selection Debate Means for India
The discussion is about more than one player’s omission. It highlights the challenge of balancing experience, current form, batting depth and bowling variety when several fast bowlers are competing for limited places.
- India backed a four-seamer attack: Bumrah, Akash Deep, Anshul Kamboj and Prasidh Krishna were selected ahead of Siraj.
- Gill acknowledged the selection difficulty: The captain said the team had spent a week discussing its bowling combination.
- Former players questioned the omission: Gavaskar, Jaffer, Bhogle and Shastri highlighted Siraj’s experience and contribution.
- The team management defended its decision: Kotak said the XI was selected with all five days of the Test in mind.
- Day 1 created a fresh talking point: New Zealand’s recovery from 70/5 to 243/5 intensified scrutiny, but did not prove that Siraj’s inclusion would have changed the partnership.
Frequently Asked Questions
Key details about Mohammed Siraj’s omission from India’s first Test playing XI against New Zealand.
India selected Jasprit Bumrah, Akash Deep, Anshul Kamboj and Prasidh Krishna as its four fast bowlers. Shubman Gill said the team had considered several bowling combinations because multiple pacers were performing well. The team management later defended the selection as a five-day combination decision.
The team explanations reported for this selection decision did not identify an injury as the reason for Siraj’s omission. Gill described it as a difficult team-combination call.
India selected Anshul Kamboj and Akash Deep alongside Jasprit Bumrah and Prasidh Krishna in its four-man pace attack.
Gavaskar expressed surprise and said Siraj had not let India down. He questioned why the experienced fast bowler was left out despite being available for the Test.
Kotak defended the selection, saying there was nothing wrong with Siraj and that India had chosen what it considered the best XI for the full five-day match, rather than selecting only for Day 1.
Final Verdict
Experience vs Team Combination
India’s Wellington selection debate
Mohammed Siraj’s omission was a significant selection call, especially because India still chose to play four specialist fast bowlers. The reaction from former cricketers showed how highly they value his experience and ability to maintain pressure in Test cricket.
Gill’s explanation and Kotak’s defence provide the team’s reasoning, while New Zealand’s recovery on Day 1 has added another layer to the discussion. The final judgement on India’s combination should consider the full Test, not just one partnership or one day’s score.
Sources and Reporting
This report uses the published team-selection details, toss comments, post-match remarks and expert reactions available on November 19, 2026.
- Times of India – India leave out Mohammed Siraj and Ravindra Jadeja
- Zee News – Gavaskar, Ashwin and other reactions to Siraj’s omission
- ThePrint / PTI – Sitanshu Kotak defends India’s selection
- The Indian Express – Gavaskar and Shastri question Siraj’s omission
- Wisden – Analysis of India’s selection combination
2 thoughts on “Why Was Mohammed Siraj Dropped for the 1st Test vs New Zealand? India’s Selection Call Explained”